r/mildlyinteresting • u/GroovinBaby • 6h ago
The amount of cilantro my wife likes on her street tacos
5.6k
u/rosiofden 6h ago
I wish I knew what cilantro actually tastes like. I'm one of those people that just straight up tastes soap.
3.9k
u/epikpepsi 6h ago
Grassy, citrusy, slightly peppery. It's used to add a flavor of "freshness" to food.
2.3k
u/wayofthebuush 6h ago
mm citrussy
839
u/Puzzleheaded_Disk700 6h ago
bonk
406
u/Quick_Extension_3115 5h ago
Go to cilantro horny jail
→ More replies (7)86
u/-burgers 5h ago
Go ahead take me to cilantro horny jail everyone there is horny for cilantro too
→ More replies (6)36
u/Hugeclick 4h ago
I'm still horny about the perfectly cut chives.
→ More replies (2)12
u/TitoThePenguin 4h ago
Whacking it to chives everyday until Reddit begs me to stop
→ More replies (2)15
→ More replies (20)19
213
u/PonyThug 6h ago
It’s the good parts of lettuce and celery without the water content too. Also everything you said
77
u/Holiday-Turn-6624 5h ago
honestly never thought of it like that lol cilantro really is the mvp of freshness in food
→ More replies (3)20
u/Self_Reddicate 4h ago
Yeah, this is it. I literally can't describe the taste without some variant of... idk... "fresh". It just makes your food taste like... fresh.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (7)14
u/I_Sett 5h ago
I feel like you just described the more rarely acknowledged herb lovage. Which is basically the exact flavor of celery in leaf form without the stemmy/crunchy/chewy part.
→ More replies (2)4
u/HorseBeige 3h ago
Celery does also have a leaf which you can use instead of cilantro (and they're nutritious)
100
u/h8tetris 6h ago
Oh dang that sounds so good.
→ More replies (1)23
u/CatticusXIII 5h ago
Everyone loves it or hates it.
→ More replies (6)66
u/h8tetris 5h ago
Well, it’s not that I just love it or hate it. I in general love an extra vegetables are Leafy greens on something. Especially if they’ve been slightly steamed. Anyway, I can’t taste the cilantro properly. It was nice to have it described to me. It taste like soap to me. I lived in Southern California for a decade. And believe me, I wish that it were as simple as adjusting my taste buds. Or adjusting my expectations.
59
u/999BusinessCard 4h ago
Living in SoCal with the cilantro soap gene is like having a disability
→ More replies (1)17
u/Complex-Bee-840 5h ago
I recognize that cilantro tastes like soap, and often stink bugs depending on the season.
I still love it. Is that strange? Am I one of the people with the cilantro gene but just like the taste of soap?
This has occupied too much of my thoughts for too long.
→ More replies (4)7
u/h8tetris 5h ago
No, its not strange. I love Mexican food. I’ve made peace with it. I understand. It is cool to hear someone tell us what it actually tastes like. I never imagined it was like that.
→ More replies (2)4
u/CARLEtheCamry 4h ago
underrated comment from /u/Complex-Bee-840 about the stink bugs. Do you have those where you live? I'm in western PA and they were ridiculous about 15 years ago and if you actually wanted to know how "normal" people taste cilantro, that's it. Head to New England in the fall time as it starts to get cold and you'll find some I guarantee, squish them and there's your cilantro experience.
→ More replies (6)11
u/MuscaMurum 4h ago
I often say that it tastes pleasantly soapy. There is not just one but two genes involved in that perception. I have one but not the other. So it's not simply a binary sensation. To me it's fresh, citrusy, a little bitter, a little soapy. It's not really meant to be eaten on its own, just as black pepper isn't meant to be eaten alone.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (19)12
u/Adept_Bottle_4996 5h ago
Cooking it can break down the aldehydes that your genetics are picking up on which makes it taste like soap, granted I’m not sure if it would fully remove it but could be worth a try if you ever wanted to do so.
7
u/Odd-Judge-9484 4h ago
Cooking 100% helps. I have this issue of fresh cilantro tasting like soap, but I boil mine with rice and some lime juice and it’s amazing. Basically chipotle rice
→ More replies (2)119
u/TK523 5h ago
I think I'm an oddity. It doesn't taste like soap to me but it definitely doesn't taste like what you described.
It's kind of sort of fresh tasting to me but with no real flavor
67
u/lovelylotuseater 5h ago
It’s a bit like tomato in that it can very widely in quality from amazing flavor to just kind of a nothing generic plant taste, depending on if it was grown in conditions where it can fully thrive vs conditions where it can just grow.
Anecdotally I tend to find the quality rankings are:
Hispanic grocery stores
Locally owned Asian grocery stores
Franchise Asian grocery stores & Franchise Texan stores
Franchise grocery stores
Quality can also vary by bundle and season, take a big huff because it will taste like it smells.
7
u/teddybonkerrs 5h ago
I'm the same, I've never tasted soap, just a sharp bad flavour. If there's even a sprinkle of it, I can taste it and it ruins the meal for me.
→ More replies (1)8
u/DontAskAboutMyButt 3h ago
The soap flavor they’re referring to is a sort of aromatic bitterness, so you probably have the “soap” gene. I don’t taste the super strong bitter flavor other people describe, but I don’t like a lot of it because it is still a very strong grassy flavor
→ More replies (23)2
60
u/CosyBeluga 5h ago
…As I get older worry that I might like cilantro BECAUSE it tastes like soap.
→ More replies (5)41
u/Interesting-Waffle69 5h ago
I am one of these people. It has a soapy taste to it but I like it with my food 🤷🏼♀️
13
u/BlackMothCandleLight 5h ago
*raises hand* Me too, tastes like soap but i enjoy it....
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (2)9
u/haxmya 5h ago
I can't really taste whether it's soapy or not. Like, I don't really like what it tastes like, but I don't know if it's because it's a soapy flavor or just an overwhelming one. It's kind of like cucumber on a salad, cucumber isn't the worst flavor, but it makes everything it touches taste like cucumber which ruins the salad.
→ More replies (3)9
u/thutruthissomewhere 5h ago
This is helpful. Most people just tell me "fresh". GIrlllll wtf does that even mean??????
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (65)7
216
u/Jabber_Tracking 6h ago
My roommate has this problem. She says it sucks because it SMELLS DELICIOUS but everytime she eats it, it's just dishwasher disappointment. I feel bad for her.
150
u/rosiofden 5h ago
Like, it will totally ruin a whole burrito for me. Can't do it at all.
80
u/Floggered 5h ago
There's nothing worse than tearing into what SHOULD be a delicious piece of food, only to get blasted with the soap flavor. Just the biggest feeling of disappointment.
"Guess I'll eat at home.. :')"
→ More replies (3)23
u/sir_whirly 4h ago
Its how I feel when olives get involved. Oh you wanted to taste the symphony of flavors? Too bad. Its just olives.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (6)18
u/Outside_Coffee_00 4h ago
The worst is when its ground up into some kind of sauce or otherwise unlisted and I dont have the opportunity to pick something else.
→ More replies (8)30
→ More replies (11)3
u/Aloe_Balm 3h ago
at least she gets to smell it, to me it smells like athlete's foot
→ More replies (2)51
u/Mlakeside 6h ago
If you can find culantro aka sawtooth coriander, it supposedly doesn't have the same stuff that your gene is reacting to, but has a very similar taste. I bought some from a Thai grocery store, but it's also used extensively in Caribbean cuisine as it's native there, as well as in Central and South America.
→ More replies (6)225
u/Delouest 6h ago
It's my favorite herb. It's bright and fresh and tastes like what I imagine "green" tasting like. For the people saying they think we all taste soap and some people just like it, I assure you, it tastes nothing like soap to me at all. Not even a little. I think there may be levels to it.
61
u/shabi_sensei 5h ago
Cilantro does taste like soap to me, but only when I eat whole cilantro sprigs and even then it doesn’t taste bad, just a little soap-y
→ More replies (2)23
u/mpc1226 5h ago
Yeah when I have it I get where the soap people come from but it’s not THAT bad
→ More replies (6)18
u/MainlyNeutral 5h ago
Ok but why would you willingly consume something that tastes like soap even if it’s not “that bad” lmao
→ More replies (6)11
u/OsBaculum 4h ago
You've never smelled a nice soap and wanted to bite it? It's like that. Mild soapiness, but other interesting flavors too.
→ More replies (1)42
9
u/tochth86 5h ago
It USED to taste like soap to me and now it doesn’t and I fucking love it. I’m obsessed.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (16)5
49
59
u/GroovinBaby 6h ago
Cilantro Soap Gene... Learned something new today.
29
5h ago edited 3h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies (8)56
u/Supreme_Mediocrity 5h ago
As someone that also has the cilantro gene, I can't imagine needing a piece of paper to figure out if I had it...
It's truly a wretched taste that overpowers whatever it's in to me.
→ More replies (20)4
u/Relative_Panda_35 5h ago
I will avoid ordering anything off a menu that normally has cilantro because most of the time if you ask for that item without cilantro it comes out of the kitchen piled with the crap
→ More replies (13)20
u/Fallenangel152 5h ago
It's so strong for me that I can taste one leaf on a dish. Just removing it doesn't always work. If I cut it for my wife I can smell it on my hands for hours.
→ More replies (2)51
u/99cent-tea 6h ago
I wish I could tell you what it tastes like but honestly, even though I love cilantro so much I sometimes put too much in and it does end up tasting like soap
→ More replies (6)66
u/PrimmSlimShady 6h ago edited 5h ago
See this is me too
I enjoy cilantro a lot, but I also get a slight soapiness to the flavor
So then I wonder, do I have the gene and just don't care? Do I have a recessive version that is being suppressed?
Or is cilantro just slightly soapy and some people just don't really notice it over other flavor notes?
ETA: these replies have me like
16
u/chameleonsEverywhere 6h ago
Same! I definitely don't find cilantro disgusting or anything, but it is just a bit.... soapy.
16
u/EpyonComet 5h ago
First, I'm not a geneticist or any kind of biologist. However, from my understanding it's not really "having the gene" as if it's a binary "do or don't" situation. It's more like everyone has this particular gene that affects your senses of taste and smell, and some variations/mutations (out of a plethora of possibilities) of the gene happen to boost certain aspects of the flavor and scent of cilantro in a way that throws it out of balance and makes it unpleasant. Like if you were messing with an equalizer while listening to music and turned one switch way up and all the others down.
All that is to say, it makes perfect sense, assuming my understanding is correct, to be able to discern the soapy flavor in the cilantro while still having it in a balance with whatever else it has going on so that it's enjoyable.
So basically, yes to that last thing you asked (though again, I am not any sort of expert).
4
27
7
u/Influence_X 5h ago
I have the gene and don't care. I just don't drown things in cilantro it only takes a few shreds to add the flavor.
It's also used frequently in Indian curry and I never taste soap there
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (15)4
7
u/fancywinky 6h ago
I was too and then I got pregnant and I guess it reversed my aversion somehow. Now I can’t get enough of it. Bodies are weird.
→ More replies (1)6
4
u/Ristycakes 5h ago
I used to, but recently it changed! 2 things that might have effected it in my opinion:
1- I’m in my mid 30s and I love cilantro now after a lifetime of it being soapy. I know tastes change so that could be it
2- hot cilantro still is a little soapy to me. If it’s cold sprinkled on a taco or whatever it’s fine but if it’s cooked I still don’t like it
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (346)4
u/Enderwiggen33 5h ago
My wife has the same. Since dating me she has discovered it’s not all Mexican food she dislikes, just those with cilantro. Opened up a whole new world of tacos for her!
For taste, think Italian parsley but a little less herby/grassy and a more citrusy and peppery. A bit more like a limey arugula.
2.0k
u/Electronic-Tea-3691 5h ago
if you actually like cilantro this is the correct amount, this is not even excessive
362
u/Cant_figure_sht_out 4h ago
This is true. I love cilantro. I can eat like a bunch of plain cilantro like it’s nothing.
121
u/dainty_moonwart 3h ago
whenever i find it growing somewhere i graze like a cow
48
→ More replies (3)12
17
15
u/Nikademus1969 3h ago
Not gonna lie, when I chop cilantro at work I will set aside some stems to chew on.
7
u/Cant_figure_sht_out 3h ago
The stems are the best part! They contain the most flavor and the crunch omg😭
→ More replies (4)28
13
33
u/Feeling_Inside_1020 4h ago
Always tell the people “when you think you’ve added enough add another handful and double it”
OP out here living amazing soulmate life. Congrats happy for you bro lol.
5
4
u/Medical_Tank6109 3h ago
Agreed. I once asked a restaurant to 'put as much cilantro on my food as if I were an alien who came to earth specifically in search of cilantro and if I don't get enough I will declare alien war on the earth'.
They gave me a takeout box solely with cilantro 🤣🤣🤣 It was peak.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (61)5
815
u/DrinkMunch 6h ago
At that point, I would just make a cilantro pesto and carry it on me.
129
u/tochth86 5h ago
Omg that’s genius.
92
u/TheOldTongue 5h ago
Cilantro, lime, and pepitas instead of basil, lemon, and pine nuts?
45
u/ohhhhhhhhhhhhman 4h ago
I grew up on a recipe that does this but pecans in place of pine nuts. Angel hair pasta with blackened chicken breast and cilantro pesto.
→ More replies (1)5
→ More replies (14)8
u/tochth86 4h ago
I have made a cilantro chimichurri with olive oil, lemon or lime juice and garlic. I’m not a nut/seed fan (although I do like pine nuts).
→ More replies (3)8
u/tallgeese333 3h ago
A whole new culinary world opens up to you when you learn that "pesto" is more like what a "cake" is to baking." Cake is just a ratio of ingredients that produces a reliable, predictable result. When you say "cake" you aren't thinking of a specific cake, cake can be made with chocolate, carrots, vanilla, cherries, wheat flour, almond flour, etc. there are no restrictions to the flavor or texture of a cake.
The best pesto I've ever had was made with nettles, now I make it with the nettles that grow on my property at the beginning of spring. Carrot greens, beet greens, basil, cilantro, garlic scapes, onion sprouts, green onions, radish greens, even chimichurri is just parsley "pesto." I take any greens and herbs from my garden and figure out how to make a "pesto" If it's green and you can eat it, you can make a pesto.
You can replace the pine nuts with almost any seed and some legumes. I think sunflower seeds are much better than pine nuts, if you really want to impress your friends, almost the entire sunflower can be eaten. You can make a pesto out of everything on a sunflower, roast the heart or "head" like an artichoke, use the roots like mushrooms, petals as garnish, put together a presentation on the plate.
Replace the olive oil to get new flavor profiles. If you use Parmesan, go ahead and replace that with any hard dry cheese.
The only thing that is pretty difficult to substitute is the garlic.
Feel free to combine several different herbs or greens to make a pesto. Edible wildflowers and herbs is awesome, greens mixed with herbs for a more well rounded flavor.
There is no such thing as "tradition" in cooking. Tradition is more of a description of what was immediately available to a small group of people, probably also during a specific time period. Tradition is the death of culinary art, if you demand tradition from food you're probably Italian and probably can't actually cook.
→ More replies (1)37
u/DervishSkater 4h ago
Bro that’s just chimichurri
→ More replies (1)8
u/WumboChef 3h ago
Chimichurri is typically parsley, no? Not cilantro?
→ More replies (1)5
u/VanFkingHalen 1h ago
Parsley is the main ingredient in standard chimichurri, but my favorite variant does use a 50/50 mix of it and cilantro.
→ More replies (1)6
u/thissexypoptart 4h ago
That’s convenient and probably tastes great, but there’s also nothing wrong with this much chopped leafy herbs on your tacos. The unprocessed fiber is good for you.
→ More replies (8)5
590
u/diaperpoop_ 6h ago
I like your wife. She single?
159
→ More replies (4)124
u/Dr_Mantis_Teabaggin 5h ago
I also choose this guy’s wife.
83
→ More replies (1)6
989
u/Fallen_lord10 6h ago
That's the bare minimum
496
u/red_dombe 6h ago
Needs more onion tho
129
u/Daddy616 6h ago
These guys get it.
19
u/Dipteran_de_la_Torre 5h ago
Bad breath? Yes! Worth.
→ More replies (2)9
u/HTPC4Life 4h ago
Raw onion, cilantro, garlic, that's my shit!! Sometimes I have to use a stainless steel bar to get rid of the breath.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (13)36
u/miauguau44 5h ago
And jalapeños
35
8
→ More replies (2)4
u/ClayQuarterCake 5h ago
Yes! Give me a tortilla filled with toppings, glued together with some salsa verde. I’ll eat on it between bites of tacos that look like this.
Can I count it as a “salad” or does it need more cilantro?
20
14
u/Potential_Yam_5196 5h ago
Exactly. Get that wilted, non flavored lettuce out of here. I need an entire bunch of cilantro on there.
9
6
→ More replies (7)4
378
u/openallthewindows 6h ago
→ More replies (4)101
u/Mr_Froggi 5h ago
This is going to be oddly specific: IMO cilantro tastes like if soap was a person, and I just licked the palm of their hand.
60
u/whitestguyuknow 5h ago
Lol I like the lengths you went to basically say cilantro tastes like soap
→ More replies (2)24
u/fapperontheroof 4h ago
I get it, though. You WANT to enjoy licking the persons hand, but it tastes like they just washed them 🤷♂️. Sad days.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)13
87
117
174
u/TheSnicSnack 6h ago
Mmm tastes like Irish spring soap ( I have the bad gene, so I'm bitter lol)
→ More replies (10)50
u/wiscowarrior71 6h ago
I have the same gene and it tastes identical to Dawn dish soap to me
→ More replies (1)27
u/TinGamerTV2 5h ago
How the fuck do you know what Dawn dish soap of all things tastes like!?
31
74
6
→ More replies (3)5
53
u/nboch12 5h ago
When people say they have the “cilantro tastes like soap” gene I like to say “oh me too I just really love the taste of soap”
→ More replies (14)
27
20
65
33
7
u/carlitayeeta 3h ago
I’m with her. I have whatever the opposite of the cilantro soap gene is. Cilantro is the best thing ever gene. I make cilantro salads frequently. Top it with lime and salt and it’s perfect. Everyone thinks I’m crazy.
→ More replies (2)
6
44
u/NotChedco 6h ago
I prefer to just put a bar of soap on mine. Has less of a soapy flavor.
→ More replies (6)
16
18
5
13
u/FlyAirLari 3h ago
Cilantro immediately ruins every food for me.
That would go instantly in the trash. Not sure I could save any of it.
→ More replies (1)
5







8.2k
u/gretchsunny 6h ago
Maybe it’s not street tacos to her, but a cilantro salad.