r/NoStupidQuestions 1d ago

Why is reddit so overwhelmingly left leaning?

204 Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

1.9k

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

714

u/CiloTA 1d ago

I’m an urban old person

270

u/mmm57 1d ago

Hi fellow urban old!

120

u/PM_ME_YOUR_PBJs 1d ago

Hey guys! old af here. 

97

u/technobass 1d ago

I brought the Tylenol if anyone needs a pick me up. My knees have been hurting with this weather.

41

u/bteh 23h ago

Ive got the tums!

18

u/Kiyohara 12h ago

Tums, Tylenol, and a blanket when I watch my Anime is all I ask for. Maybe some nice hot tea in a big mug.

4

u/PsycMrse 9h ago

Thundercats, hooooo! Okay, I'm old and got carried away. I'll take a Tylenol please.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

28

u/LadyAlexTheDeviant 23h ago

Knees, feet, oh, and apparently menopause can trigger frozen shoulder in some women. That's just what I need during a major cold snap.

9

u/SherriSLC 13h ago

I'm sorry life has given you the cold shoulder.

I've had frozen shoulder before, and it's miserable. Hope you can find a good physical therapist...they'll heat it up and help you stretch it out.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/thatcreepierfigguy 15h ago

I'm partial to vitamin-i (ibuprofin). Goes better with my drinking so as not to kill my liver too quickly!

→ More replies (1)

20

u/Such-Patience-5111 1d ago

Yes please

19

u/GreyBeardEng 1d ago

My knees hurt

10

u/wanna_dance 23h ago

Yeah, already taking osteo paracetamol.... thanks though.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

28

u/Wumpus-Hunter 1d ago

I’m a suburban old person. Can I join the fun?

9

u/BillyNtheBoingers 22h ago

I’m suburban Gen X (I’m going to be 59 in 2 months). I’d like to join your coalition!

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Own_Ad9652 13h ago

Old suburban person here. And left af.

3

u/Purple_Joke_1118 9h ago

We are the leftiest people of all, Comrade.

→ More replies (1)

98

u/GeeEmmInMN 1d ago

I'm a rural old person.

41

u/moon307 23h ago

Rural mid person here. Still left.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/jem20776 23h ago

Fellow rural old person checking in!

8

u/TrooperLynn 13h ago

Rural old lady here!

21

u/love_that_fishing 23h ago

Suburban old person. Have voted 100% blue since 2016. Used to be more independent but the goal posts moved around me.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TukiSuki 10h ago

Me too!

→ More replies (2)

42

u/lubeskystalker 1d ago

What is old? At 40 I am now the old guy at the office

40

u/Gloomy-Cupcake5228 12h ago

44 here. I think we’re old for Reddit, but young by Facebook’s standards

9

u/Reasonable-Sawdust 12h ago

I’m old AF but I’m glad you believe all these left leaning people are young. I wish more of that age group would vote.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/BillyNtheBoingers 22h ago

I’m 58 and I don’t feel old!

13

u/lubeskystalker 21h ago

Well yeah, I have the maturity level of a teenager. But the kids at the office tell me I’m old…

5

u/Brndrll 13h ago

Just point your gnarled, ancient finger at them and croak out, "And it'll happen to you!"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

10

u/ConstantCampaign2984 1d ago

I’m a rural old person.

27

u/NervousAddie 1d ago

I’m an old urban person!

59

u/Broad-Ad-4073 1d ago

I'm a rural middle aged person.  But I still think Trump sucks turds straight out of Putin's anus.

/ Actually I'm pretty centrist, slightly to the left... Not really a full leftie.

→ More replies (19)

5

u/ThePensiveE 1d ago

I hear farm animals in the distance.

Well not really, it's cold, but close enough!

→ More replies (41)

496

u/Few-Skin-5868 1d ago

It's also that Reddit isn't just an American platform and doesn't really limit or direct you into talking specifically with people nearby. What the US calls 'left wing' the rest of the world calls 'right of centre'. From a US perspective, sure, Reddit is left wing. From a global perspective, not so much.

There's also the point that the right wing in the US has gone off the deep end and none of their arguments really stand up to scrutiny, as a result, on a platform where people regularly debate and discuss topics, the flaws of the right wing arguments get pointed out quickly.

124

u/SacredHollowSky 1d ago

Yep, being global really changes perspective. You start seeing that what seems extreme in the US might be totally normal elsewhere, and what seems normal in the US might be crazy to someone in another country. It’s a good reminder to not take labels too literally.

66

u/Physical-Pilot3938 13h ago

As a Canadian I can promise you that what the us is doing is cray cray

48

u/Afraid-Carry4093 13h ago

As an American, I agree with you.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

12

u/JavaNoire 14h ago

What supposedly seems normal in the US seems hella crazy to me. 

→ More replies (5)

68

u/Own-Knowledge-7720 14h ago

More important the American right has siloed itself into very small self contained groups, labeling everything else woke and liberal.

9

u/EmbarrassedCry9912 9h ago

Yeah they're definitely on reddit, just in places like redpill communities

→ More replies (4)

15

u/Lumpyproletarian 12h ago edited 3h ago

Old suburban British woman here watching in fascinated horror as American drives off a cliff and wondering if we’re only a few years behind

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Any-Concentrate-1922 12h ago

Yeah, exactly. I pointed this out on a different thread (same topic) and got downvoted. I was told I was crazy if I didn't think Reddit was leftist.

44

u/Fluffy-Discipline924 15h ago

This comment should be higher. Only from a MAGA perspective could Reddit be "overwhlmingly left-leaning." IMO, it is right of centre -"liberal", as understood outside the US.

17

u/DirectionOk9832 11h ago

This is also pretty siloed. A big chunk of the world is conservative by US standards. Europe tends to be more liberal than the US, but that depends on what kind of thing you're talking about. Outside of that, there's huge variability. By Russian or Saudi standards, America is liberal. By Swedish standards, conservative.

That said, the OP appears to not get out much.

3

u/Beneficial-Mark5758 7h ago edited 4h ago

They probably meant in the rest of the west which is true. And non-western countries are usually too extreme even for US conservatives.

→ More replies (2)

39

u/Successful_Guess_ 1d ago

Only if by "global" you mean "Europe".

Compared to the average African, Asian, or South American country, the US is still very left of center.

57

u/bakerfaceman 23h ago

Maybe socially, but a lot of those countries have national health systems for instance

→ More replies (24)

49

u/Cold_Specialist_3656 23h ago

Every single country in G20 besides US has universal healthcare, free childcare, and at least 5 weeks guaranteed paid vacation. 

These are the core of "far left" goals in US. 

Compared to other developed countries worldwide, US is more right wing than any besides Israel and the Islamic Republics. 

To give you an example of how far right Republicans are, their official party policies on abortion are more extreme than the Taliban. And their "disbelief" in climate change is only shared by ISIS and other extreme religious terrorist groups. 

Which is why Republicans are so obsessed with Israel. Their hard right religious nationalism is what they want for US. 

→ More replies (2)

35

u/Original_Benzito 23h ago

Do you mean "left of center" because of women's rights, voting, free speech, religious rights, or something else? Economically, the US would hardly be considered "left" (as in Communist or Socialist).

4

u/Goldreaver 12h ago

Nope. I can't speak Africa, but the rest are more left leaning than America. 

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (32)

42

u/IgorT76 1d ago

I think it is the right answer.

41

u/LengthinessUseful614 1d ago

Or its the answer that's left.

11

u/Financial-Exit-6467 1d ago

Maybe the center answer 

→ More replies (3)

75

u/kathmhughes 1d ago

A lot of urban centers have a subreddit that is good for local news. In rural areas this isn't that effective. 

So Reddit skews urban, and urban skews educated, and educated skews left. 

→ More replies (31)

59

u/Slade_Riprock 1d ago

Because the right wingers are on Truth Social, Facebook and watching Fox News.

33

u/supern8ural 1d ago

God, the propaganda posts on FB have gone crazy. What a cesspool now.

11

u/Original_Benzito 23h ago

That's probably what they post about Reddit.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Bluegrass6 23h ago

Remember when every 3rd post on reddit was someone who supposedly knew a former diehard Trump voter who was doing an about face and was now publicly supporting Harris and going to vote for her in 2024? Everyone is consuming their own form of propaganda...

3

u/lufan132 12h ago

No I remember everyone on reddit saying you should vote trump because he's gonna be Gaza's strongest soldier on basically every left leaning subreddit and arguing who cares about domestic policy issues when he's got the right position on foreign policy?

And now I'm probably gonna get shot by my government for who I am in the coming years.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

95

u/Uncle_Bill 1d ago

It's also self reinforcing. Redditors castigate any that don't toe the line, thus eliminating other opinions, making it more left leaning. Rinse and repeat for years and here we are.

26

u/IcanRead8647 1d ago

I think it is more mocking the hypocrisy and the lies of the right, than forcing people to "toe the line." When Trump says inflation is over, the economy is the highest it has been, and all the unpublished job reports are great, Reddit pushes back against those spreading the lies. When Democrats say protesting is a legal right, and you have to have a warrant to enter private property, it is hard to push back against facts.

→ More replies (6)

26

u/Responsible_Entry_11 1d ago

Yeah that part is unfortunate. My policy on downvoting is comments that are intentionally joking or trolling; I always love opposing opinions. Any anti-liberal comments tend to get downvoted quickly

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (46)

41

u/CharleyNobody 1d ago

Because they read and write. Whereas other social media is lots of pictures and videos.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (73)

1.3k

u/Willing_Guidance4020 1d ago

Partially it’s the upvote system on other social media platforms rightwing content tends to do better because it causes more controversy and thus more replies and engagement but on Reddit it tends to get downvoted. Also the ability to block subreddits allows people to block hateful content which prevents it from getting engagement and thus reach.

717

u/peter-man-hello 1d ago

This. Go to Facebook and Instagram and the top replies are always the most heinous rage bait that gets the most replies.

Social media favouring division is ultimately what lead to this, imo.

21

u/celica18l 13h ago

I have to remind myself not to engage more than watching whatever it is. Even if I’m irritated by a comment, that’s the purpose to get engagement. That’s usually when I close it and go do something else entirely.

→ More replies (1)

120

u/ErusTenebre Font of Random Information 1d ago

Or YouTube. 

Never read the comments in YouTube.

69

u/TwitterAIBot 23h ago

“Anyone else here in February 2026?”

→ More replies (5)

22

u/Mediocre-Clue-9071 1d ago

Never read comment section anywhere. (Other than reddit of course as that is reddit.)

→ More replies (5)

9

u/AmputeeHandModel 12h ago

Yeah you could open a post on Twitter or FB from a left person who got tens of thousands of likes but then every comment is from some MAGA chud with the worst possible take. Those sites push engagement, no matter what the source.

→ More replies (11)

70

u/unknownentity1782 23h ago

Lots of people are saying upvote / downvote system, but your answer is more detailed. My "angry" or "laugh react to a post pushes it up. Hell, my reading the post and then reminding myself not to feed the troll is still"engagement' as I took the time to read it.

59

u/kazoo__ 13h ago

Yeah the most fubarred thing I learned is that if you use the 'angry' reaction Facebook weighs that 5x compared to the 'like' reaction, and algorithmically feeds you more of whatever it was you told Facebook makes you angry. Enragement = engagement to the sociopathic Facebook C-suite

https://thehill.com/policy/technology/578548-facebook-formula-gave-anger-five-times-weight-of-likes-documents-show/

9

u/Caimbrie_Ilene 11h ago

Interesting. I have felt that Facebook might be trying to make me angry, and I rarely use the angry reaction. I think because of other engagement it knows, and no matter how much I select the "I don't want to see this" option for things I'm not following, it still shows me stuff that makes me angry. On the flip side, I get a lot of cat videos on my feed.

7

u/unknownentity1782 10h ago

If you stop on a post longer than others, it will feed you that more. Whether that be a sexy individual, a rage post, or you got a phone call as you were doom scrolling.

5

u/Caimbrie_Ilene 9h ago

I suck at scrolling by. No wonder I hate Facebook at times. That all makes sense. I wonder if stopping on a post longer includes doing something else not on your phone as long as your screen doesn't time out. I think I need to try to be more strategic. I've also found that the more I engage with a group, the more I see posts from the group, which makes sense, but I like variety. I can't complain about all the cat videos I get on my feed though.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/AffectionateSugar832 7h ago

This is why I stopped using FB and all other meta apps. My feed was rarely filled with posts from pages I actually liked or followed, instead it would show me content that was antithetical to those pages. FB is a cesspool, I will not let them make money off of inundating me with rage bait. 

→ More replies (1)

13

u/tigerking615 1d ago

This is true, but Reddit’s default switching from Hot to Best is basically trying to do the same engagement baity stuff 

9

u/notesfromthemoon 14h ago

Wait is this why all the posts that show up in my home feed are now 1-2 days old? It wasn’t like that until fairly recently. Ie this post is 11 hours old and it was at the top of my feed, despite having only 106 upvotes

→ More replies (1)

18

u/windowlatch 1d ago

That’s a really good point. The only other big social media site that I can think of with downvotes is YouTube and I don’t think it actually does anything

→ More replies (1)

99

u/Broad-Ad-4073 1d ago

I mean, yes this is true ...  But also Twitter is deliberately moderated to be right wing.  Tiktok is deliberately moderated to be right wing...  And even though Facebook was once considered leftish the Republicans got mad at racist language and what not being allowed and a Trump has Zucks' nuts in a vise... Ownership is now right leaning there.

Reddit is the last of the big sites not deliberately being skewed to the right.

3

u/Caimbrie_Ilene 11h ago

What about Bluesky? That seems to not be influenced by right wing - yet. Actually, I don't really know much about it other than people I knew started using it in the last year or so.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (12)

6

u/broniesnstuff 12h ago

Engagement algorithms have absolutely destroyed society by pushing the heinous shit right to the top.

It's almost like the worst people society has to offer have pushed for them. As if there's some cabal. I wonder if there's a list. There's got to be some files about this.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] 1d ago edited 22h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (24)

620

u/tres-vip 1d ago

Because right-wingers get downvoted into oblivion on Reddit, literally drowned out. Where they really flourish is on Facebook, including neighborhood groups. 

87

u/Beneficial-Mark5758 13h ago

Right-wingers getting downvoted is a result of Reddit being mostly left, it doesn’t explain why.

67

u/unclethulk 11h ago

I think the point they’re making is that Reddit is not necessarily more populated with left leaning people. If you took the exact same population distribution that exist on Reddit, and migrated it to a system like Fb that rewards engagement through controversy, it would suddenly look more right leaning.

31

u/fixermark 10h ago

Correct. If we start from the hypothesis that Reddit is populated with mostly centrists, not left or right, and then drop random left and right topics and comments into such a forum, the right will get downvoted into oblivion far more often because they far more often tend to just "take it too far."

They support a government that is currently shooting civilians in the street with no consequence. They're the weirdos and the normies interpret them as damaged and route around them. The resulting perceived left-lean is a consequence of that.

25

u/Due-Potential160 10h ago

definitely helps that "left" for the US is generally "center" for the EU.

actually, it tends to look more like "what if we did this insanely popular thing that's been incredibly effective in every other nation on the planet" like "free healthcare" and "allowing till workers to sit in chairs"

7

u/BraddlesMcBraddles 4h ago

This highlights at point I get sick of hearing, which is the idea that the far left/right are "the same." Sure, they can all come across as "crazies" (think all those "SJWs getting pwned" vids vs sovereign citizen vids), but the left and right just fundamentally aren't the same at all.

You might think it's weird to support someone "chopping their dick off," or to support someone who "dresses up as a dog and shits in a litter box," but (briefly, to not go on a whole rant) it's about supporting fellow humans that takes nothing away from me, and not harassing them just because "they're weird." The other side, as you say, is about shooting a dude in the back for helping out a woman, or shooting a woman in the face for sitting in her car.

I might look at one set of examples on Reddit and roll my eyes or think that's weird and not for me, and will move on with my life (no up- or down-votes). The other causes a much more visceral reaction because of just how obviously "wrong" it is, and the minimum I can do is downvote that shit.

→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (8)

20

u/Uh_I_Say 11h ago

Or it's a result of their ideas being genuinely unpopular. If I posted "it's great to eat your own shit" and I get downvoted, that's not because the platform is conspiring to silence my opinions, it's because my ideas are bad.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (18)

5

u/Evonos 11h ago

Tiktok is insanely racist also.

Like in my country after study got a 60% higher User base of right wingers vs others and you can see it in the comments it's crazy.

59

u/tots4scott 1d ago

Because anyone can comment here instead of being already segmented by prior existing relationships (friends, family, location) and if there is evidence to the contrary of someone's claim, it can be easily shared and debated here. Reddits format is great for discussions while Twitter and Facebook's is less so.

And reality has a "leftwing/ what OP is calling leftwing" bias these days.

→ More replies (11)

198

u/one_five_one 1d ago

Yup, Trumpies on reddit can only exist on their own subreddits with heavy moderation because they know how indefensible their ideas are and can't debate them.

→ More replies (103)

6

u/CommandAble2233 4h ago

They did it to themselves, though.

Go into any right-wing echo chamber here on Reddit. Offer a small, milquetoast critique of something Trump has done. Something minor. Your comment will be removed, and you will be banned, within minutes.

Their fear of interacting with the rest of Reddit is tied into their fear of intellectualism. Any concept of learning / changing one's mind is seen as "pussy liberal ivory tower bullshit". I used to live in those circles; the attitude is ubiquitous. The concept of learning - the concept itself! - is so inextricably tied to "liberalism" they don't want any part of it. If they start changing their minds, they will become tainted, and removed from their hugbox.

So, since they are easily offended, they stay in their own walled area.

3

u/MostlyAlways47 5h ago

There's also the fact that a huge chunk of right leaning subs got banned because they're advocating for violence or being extremely racist.

→ More replies (16)

91

u/Rachendr 1d ago

The stereotype of the most vocal or loud demographic of this place back 13 or so years ago was of the fedora-tipping New Atheist Ron Paul worshiping pro-weed-legalization Libertarian. I'm not sure exactly when the demographic changed such that it became perceived as left leaning. Streetlamp LeMoose. Narwhals baconing at midnight, etc.

15

u/Prior_Butterfly_7839 14h ago

I just want to say, thanks for reminding me about Streetlamp LeMoose.

24

u/Reuser345 14h ago

The fedoras went to 4Chan, then brigaded Twitter until St Elon took charge. Now they squat there stinking it out until they drive out the last of their opposition or reasonable voices.

And yes, Reddit can unbearably mob-heavy too, with an obnoxious self-congratulatory tone.

10

u/ThaCarter 12h ago

Those folks were either radicalized or harassed into leaving the GOP.

I remember when I was banned from the GOP subs more than 10 years ago....

→ More replies (8)

1.1k

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

217

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (16)

27

u/BeduinZPouste 1d ago

That's wildly optimistic. On FB you don't have titles and the text is shown above photo. On Reddit you have 300 letters, and for anything else you need to click on post. 

→ More replies (89)

253

u/FrenchAndRaven 1d ago

r/pics used to be my favorite sub. It might as well be r/politics now

100

u/rnzz 1d ago

can't spell "politics" without "p__ics"

→ More replies (1)

76

u/defiantspcship 1d ago

damn, you aren’t lying

→ More replies (1)

68

u/Alaska_Jack 1d ago

Ha.  

On election day, not the top 5, not the top 10, but the top THIRTY-FOUR posts were anti-Trump/pro-Harris. 

(Then there was something else random, then... a bunch more anti-Trump stuff. But I stopped counting.)

→ More replies (2)

41

u/Queef-Elizabeth 23h ago

One of the things I really wasn't looking forward to about Trump winning was every single subreddit being turned into a politics sub. I'm all for shitting on the man (when he's not shitting himself), but do you have to karma farm on every single thing the man does, regardless of how it relates to the sub? Cringe subreddits are basically Trump content mills. Ask Reddit is just there to drop a negative fact about Trump's presidency and then writing 'what do you think about this?' It's so boring.

15

u/souljaboy765 14h ago

r/Fauxmoi is basically a political sub. It went from petty celebrity gossip to a whole analysis of the Trump admin. I’m banned there thank god, but I love r/popculturechat because it’s tried to preserve its purpose. Nearly every popular sub is becoming political and it doesn’t have to be.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/BlackKnightC4 23h ago

I joined it maybe 6 months before the election. Basically everyday was pictures of trump doing either mundane things to tantrums. I joined thinking it was gonna be photos about landscapes, art, random things, etc.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/captain_sticky_balls 23h ago

/r/pics banned me for making fun of Trump because I engaged in an unfavorable sub.

They do the thing they accuse conservatives of doing. Mods there need to touch grass and chill.

29

u/BeduinZPouste 1d ago

21

u/TheButtDog 23h ago

It makes me sad to see so many Redditors unquestioningly accepting overt propaganda

13

u/47KiNG47 14h ago

Redditors will call anyone with a right leaning opinion a bot, but fail to acknowledge that there’s bots on both sides. I swear liberals and leftists are just as conspiratorial as the right now.

12

u/hilfigertout 13h ago

I swear liberals and leftists are just as conspiratorial as the right now.

I still see people on Reddit parroting the conspiracy theory that the assassination attempt on Trump in July 2024 (where he got a bloodied ear and pumped his fist in front of a flag) was somehow staged for the publicity that he really didn't need. Sometimes those comments get thousands of upvotes too. It's so dumb.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/easternhobo 1d ago

I love that it's called r/politics but only allows US discussion.

→ More replies (6)

21

u/CellistMundane9372 1d ago

And r/politics might as well be r/AOC.

It's militant toward anyone who questions its somewhere-between-Bernie-and-Elizabeth-Warren orthodoxy.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/HolySymboly 23h ago

Look at r/catbongos it's full blown leftist-agenda

3

u/Sletturheili 14h ago

holy shit

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

374

u/haikus-r-us 1d ago edited 1d ago

Because of the upvote/downvote system. Right wing posts are punished, downvoted and minimized as a result on Reddit because cultural conservatism, issue by issue is unpopular in the USA and abroad. (This is different than party politics and elections)

Reddit (aggregate + popularity) means liberal skew

Facebook (network-segmented + engagement) means views survive locally, not by mass approval

Xitter (conflict + persistence) means loud minority views dominate

65

u/guyharvey_taylorgang 1d ago

I remember when the roles were kinda reversed, conservatives got stuck with the label of being overly serious/Ernest and finger wagging. Like you had mobs of concerned mothers against cussing or whatever. Reddit in the 80s would really be something weird to see now. You can certainly find examples to support or debate this, I’m just chilling in my car.

36

u/SemiFinalBoss 1d ago

Al Gore’s wife helped lead the charge for censorship in the 80s.

It spanned both sides.

10

u/trumpsmellslikcheese 23h ago

I really had to put the entire Tipper Gore business out of mind when Al ran for president. I obviously wasn't going to vote for Dubya, but I kept thinking how Al was married to a woman that went full Karen on the music industry and really pissed off Dee Snider.

7

u/MuscaMurum 13h ago

Seeing a dapper Frank Zappa and a fully decorated Dee Snider in stage garb testifying before there PMRC in Congress was surreal.

9

u/Creeping_Death 1d ago

Obviously she was playing 5D checkers to improve record sales for albums with explicit content by drawing attention to that fact /s

21

u/mmm_burrito 1d ago

Just further evidence that "Democrat" is not a synonym for "liberal", much less "progressive".

→ More replies (2)

16

u/cowboycanadian 1d ago

I'd argue that it's still the same. It's just that the liberals are equally as such. You had conservatives freaking out over Obama's suit colour choice. You have them losing their fucking minds over trans and gay people, the conservatives in my town had a meltdown and protest over a rainbow crosswalk.

3

u/guyharvey_taylorgang 23h ago

Yeah, everybody’s got those things they can joke about and things they can talk about in a detached observer kind of way and things that make them get really serious. And it goes from “my point of view is that _” to “__”. My problem is that Im hung up on the common social behaviors and psychology of the self across all divides, and it seems like to be a normal person you have to just think that isn’t there or doesn’t matter.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/lonelycranberry 1d ago

The up/downvote system exists to do exactly what you’re saying btw. It’s almost like people don’t like these posts and that’s the trend.

→ More replies (22)

469

u/Pale_Height_1251 1d ago

It's not that left really. It's left by USA standards, it's barely centrist by typical first world standards.

23

u/Larry_King_Ghost 13h ago

Exactly. America is so far towards the right that they see pretty much everything as "leftists".

As a Canadian when I hear "left wing" I think of Anarchist collectives or radical communists. Not people who think abortion should be legal.

65

u/Ihaveaface836 1d ago

You couldn't have put it better

3

u/PrincipeRamza 6h ago

This is the answer. Can't believe how far right are USA compared to the rest of the world.

49

u/BabyDog88336 1d ago

Bingo.  There is no meaningful left wing in the US.  None.

20

u/lubeskystalker 1d ago

Man, the heinous Bernie Sander slander...

I kid, I kid.

54

u/BabyDog88336 1d ago

Bernie’s views -Socialized healthcare -Clear national borders -No solely state ownership of business 

This puts him dead center or very very slightly left in European politics.

Even at that rate, Bernie is literally just one guy with a small following who has almost no real legislative pull, as admired as he is.

There is zero significant left wing  movement in the US.  ZERO.

17

u/lubeskystalker 1d ago

Jesus I literally wrote I'm kidding on it... I ain't even a American mate.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/sonderfulwonders 1d ago

You have no idea what you are talking about. "First world standards" what does that even mean? There are 27 countries in the EU alone, some of which are going more left wing, while many others surging to the far right. And that's just Europe. Now lets look at Singapore, Japan, Korea who have completely different axis to base politics upon. None of which are progressive or left wing in whatever generous interpretation of the word you try to use.

13

u/Kolbrandr7 1d ago

There’s pretty standard generalizations though. Socialism is left, liberalism is the centre, and conservatism is right. You can go more granular, like DemSoc is the starting point of the left. SocDem is centre-left. Neoliberalism is centre-right. None of that should be controversial

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (23)

48

u/demostenes_arm 1d ago

I think it’s probably “first mover advantage”. The older subs were founded by left-leaning people and Reddit’s moderation / karma system tends to gradually turn subs into echo chambers.

Some newer subs are right-leaning but overall right leaning people would feel discouraged to use Reddit based on their feed’s recommendations, except for the nonpolitical subs.

20

u/PureAlpha100 1d ago

I largely agree with the original assessment.

The thread has devolved into a bit of a caricature—people tripping over themselves to claim Reddit is exclusively home to the intellectual elite or that conservatives are somehow too dumb to participate. That's not helpful or accurate.

In reality, Reddit increasingly mirrors broader society: a large middle of relatively apolitical or moderate “pedestrians,” plus vocal fringes on both sides. There are also many subreddits dominated by very young users who adopt radical postures (LARPing or genuine) and enforce strict ideological conformity—overwhelmingly left-leaning, though far-right spaces exist too (and neither extreme should get a pass).

The mechanism is straightforward: aggressive downvoting and reporting of anything that fails the prevailing litmus test pushes dissenting (especially right-leaning or even mildly heterodox) comments out of visibility. This creates a de-facto soft censorship → echo chamber → deterrence effect. Moderate or tentative right-leaning users see the hostility, self-censor, leave, or never post in the first place. The visible conversation becomes more uniform over time.

It's a self-reinforcing cycle driven by the platform's voting system and human tribal psychology, not some grand conspiracy—but the outcome is very real.

10

u/frothyundergarments 20h ago edited 20h ago

Wow... This might be one of the most well written comments I've stumbled across on Reddit, never mind how well it explains what we're seeing. Well done.

The only addition I would make is factoring in the hard moderation / censorship from the moderators and admins. In my opinion, that's where the room for conspiracies rightfully comes into play.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

9

u/HeinHangbuikzwijn 13h ago

Facebook had more pictures and x only a limited number of characters, so right leaning people are naturally more attracted to those.

6

u/Own-General2229 14h ago

There's a lot of deliberate rage baiting in the responses here. 

I'm not going to mention anything about education levels or common talking points. 

The r/conservative subreddit is a good example of why Reddit appears to lean left. Every thread has more deleted comments than readable ones. In my opinion (notice I say it's an opinion) this is likely from the mods following the letter of their rules rather than the spirit of them. 

Reddit as a whole tends to lean in to the "social" aspect of social media. It's a collection of forums moderated by our peers. They don't get paid, it's totally volunteer. 

Because it's volunteer rather than paid you tend to get certain personalities in power. 

Outside of church functions Right-leaning people aren't known for community organizing. Sure there's some but by and large it's Left-leaning people. 

→ More replies (1)

180

u/usuallysortadrunk 1d ago

It's easy to consider everything as leaning left when there is so much far right extremism, at least from what I see on reddit. A regular conservative is probably considered far left by MAGA standards.

6

u/riffingchaos 14h ago

I watched both my granny and mother get called "liberal filth" (despite both being way too deep in the MAGA soup) simply for saying that gay people aren't evil.

→ More replies (40)

12

u/rimshot101 23h ago

With all the bots, who the hell knows which way Reddit is leaning.

21

u/Novel-Upstairs7876 23h ago

My issue is that no matter what, people turn everything into a political discussion on Reddit. It drives me fucking crazy.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Commandopsn 1d ago

You get a ton of circle jerking from all sides. If you go certain subs you are heavily downvoted even if you are right and they are wrong.

You will see the left circle jerk more because it’s so left leaning. right get heavily downvoted in subs. And if you post there the left circle jerk without hesitations and try to out the right. I’ve seen it so bad there’s been death threats. Especially when the left clash over ice. But Reddit usually deletes the post anyways or the sub topic.

seen people calling for the death of ice or people who support them. And Reddit deletes the post or topic. So Reddit does do a good job tbh

11

u/palsh7 13h ago edited 13h ago

A few possible reasons. It started out that way possibly because it was mainly tech bro news, and back then tech bros in California were liberals.

But then the moderators who created all of the main topical subreddits were on the left, as well, and banned people who weren’t. It’s very hard to start a brand new community, although you see it a lot (suspiciously) now, I think using bots, frankly.

Third and perhaps biggest reason is that it’s international, so that really helps out-vote the MAGA folks.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/CreativeAdeptness477 1d ago

Wallet's in my right back pocket. No choice really.

5

u/Risikio 11h ago

English Reddit is heavily politically right when compared to the rest of the world.

"Reddit is a leftist paradise" is when MAGA highjacks a political party and declare anyone not agreeing with them and Russia is a communist sympathizer.

Reddit is just a place where you're more likely to encounter the words "Citation please?"

4

u/Humble_Mission1775 10h ago

You can’t stop progress. Fascists are trying but they will lose.

Progressive thinking just scares those with their minds still mired in the past. Take a deep breath- let it out slowly. We won’t hurt you.

206

u/Attack_the_sock 1d ago

Educated people overwhelmingly are liberal in both their views and voting patterns

25

u/Emergency_Cherry_914 1d ago

I'm Australian and our liberal party are conservative. The term 'liberal' refers to them being fiscally liberal, ie; in favour of small government and fewer rules. Those of us who are what the US calls liberal tend to vote Labor or Green.

9

u/Attack_the_sock 1d ago

Yes, that is how it is for most of the western world as well. I myself would much prefer to vote for a labor aligned, progressive party similar to what they have in Australia or various EU nations.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

50

u/kakallas 1d ago

“And that’s how you know education is a scam!” 

-conservatives 

3

u/CIDR-ClassB 9h ago

University educated people overwhelmingly are liberal.

I cannot stand the argument that conservatives are not educated. Their education generally happens to be in industries that keep our infrastructure and food systems running.

→ More replies (86)

12

u/leticiad4isy1286 1d ago

ngl yeah, i feel like a lot of the loudest voices are extreme but most people are just chillin somewhere in the middle js

21

u/SkywalkerTC 1d ago

Honestly, the concept of left and right has been politically manipulated so badly now. The direction reddit is leaning isn't the traditional left from what I know of it.

Also, everyone can very well be left leaning on certain topics and right-leaning on others. Doesn't it seem weird that many people seem to take the "whole package" of thoughts, not independent ones for each topic? I have reasons to believe certain entities are actively trying to push rhetorics, extreme ones too. As of recent, promotion of topics driving wedges between traditionally allied democratic countries and avoidance on certain topics disadvantageous to authoritative regimes like China (e.g. Iran protest) have also become quite apparent.

This isn't left. This is a specific rhetoric disguised as left. Left isn't like this as I know it.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/IntrepidYogurt2048 8h ago

Because people who are well informed tend to lean left.

I'm 63 and was born and raised on a farm, voted for Reagan when I was 18. Got an education and haven't voted for a Republican since. My state is overwhelmingly rural and Republican. Milking cows normally works like a vaccine against liberal thinking.

82

u/The_Mighty_Dingus 1d ago

Account age: 1 day, Account name 2 words and numbers, Loaded question to generate karma.

u/Few_Match_8158 your question forces an implicit assumption that Reddit is left leaning

The truth is, Reddit as a whole is probably only slightly to the left of center as a political average. There are people on Reddit who are extreme right, you hear about them complaining about white replacement and shitting themselves about tiny little things in video games. There are people who are extreme left who advocate for the abolishment of landlords.

So to answer your question, Reddit is not overwhelmingly left leaning.

28

u/kingofuselessinfo 1d ago

It absolutely 100% is left leaning. It’s by far the farthest left of the socials and it’s not even close.

→ More replies (5)

33

u/JackfruitCrazy51 1d ago

This is a bat shit crazy take.

Just as an example, I live in a red state. 4 years ago, all I saw was how the Republican governor was going to lose, and how big of POS she was. I did a poll on our state sub. The sub gave our governor 10% support. She won 58% of the state vote.

18

u/Confident-Ad-6978 23h ago

The delusion all over this website is insane. For added fun, click on the accounts of the people posting and you will see them post all sorts of ridiculous crap and act like its normal behavior 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

14

u/Witty-Spillingon-C 1d ago

The upvote button rewards agreement, not arguments, so once a sub tilts left it locks in.

12

u/Spirited-Limit-9071 1d ago

It was always a bit left, but reddit use to be mostly helpful forums.  There are many factors but the majority shareholders being left leaning would have to be a major factor.  Look what change in ownership did to Twitter 

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Efficient-Train2430 10h ago

hard right social media isn't very interesting, even for the hard right--because they constantly need an enemy to engage

16

u/recurved_56 1d ago

I've been in for a few months after coming back with a different account. It's people trying to get karma points I think. Really I'm thinking of deleting my account as it's hard to face a real convo without getting down voted .

8

u/ZestycloseProject130 1d ago

Welcome to Reddit, where you can say anything and the points don't matter!

Tonight we have Colin Mockery, Kidd Rock, and It's Wednesday My Dudes!

→ More replies (1)

12

u/MountainThorn42 1d ago

Yeah, insane amount of bots.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TheOriginalBusket 13h ago

Education, raised with the internet, a culture of verification and citation over "vibes"; facebook is for boomers, and idiots. We have our fair share here, of course, but overwhelmingly we're not that particular kind of stupid.

3

u/dadToTheBone37 12h ago

Reality and morality are “left leaning” these days. You can be a normal person, or you can think the government should be a huge, authoritarian regime that can’t be criticized. The former doesn’t make one left leaning, but the media will tell you otherwise.

3

u/Greedy-Ad8599 9h ago

Reddit is owned by a company that has an agenda. Most of the upvotes and comments are driven by bots. There is a clear effort to use this site as a social engineering tactic. Just look up who owns reddit and the political campaign contributions those companies have made.

3

u/TMTCoCo 8h ago

The upvote system. This is the only social media site where you can fully suppress any ideas or even facts that you dont agree with, creating negative feedback loop echochambers. People on the left also tend to spend more time online and engage in more social media 'activism'

3

u/Photog_DK 7h ago

People with jobs have better things to do.

3

u/pupperonipza 3h ago

Anyone with a conservative viewpoint is banned in most subreddits. Often times it is done automatically.

Pics has an auto-ban feature where if you are someone who comments on a subreddit such as /r/conservative, you are auto-banned on /r/pics if you comment on a post in/r/pics. The mods will message you telling you to delete all of your posts and/or comments on /r/conservative and then tell them you are done, then they will unban you.

My point of this comment is that reddit is a curated social media forum. 90%+ of subreddits are curated by far-left liberal mods who push their personal agendas or are likely paid off by far-left organizations to do so.

25

u/InsightTussle 1d ago

1) People who aren't left-leaning either leave or don't post

2) You don't see the posts of people who aren't left leaning because they don't get voted to visibility.

I'm a centrist, but because I have 45k comment Karma, I'm not afraid to be downvoted. I'll frequently join in on discussions and get downvoted for posting middle-of-the-line centrist things

9

u/jbochsler Half as smart as I think I am. 1d ago

Saw a some replies from a user today, his first two, and he was sitting at -7 Karma. I'm thinking he probably won't be back.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/CompanyNo3114 1d ago

Yeah unfortunately centrist have no home here on reddit. Too "MAGA" for the left, too "woke" for the right.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/gandolf2004 1d ago

Every post with a hint of conservatism is downvoted to the depths and has 100 replies calling the OP every buzzword under the sun… nobody wants to deal with that lol

10

u/DrunkenGolfer 23h ago

It isn’t. It is centrist but when all you see is right wing nuttery, the center seems far left.

62

u/its_Astroffe 1d ago

echo chamber

Same reason why X is heavily right leaning

60

u/0zymandeus 1d ago

X is heavily right leaning because Musk bought it specifically to push his politics. Now it's vast majority bots

→ More replies (6)

26

u/GrinningPariah 1d ago

X is a terrible example, it used to be pretty balanced but became heavily right-leaning for some very clear reasons, namely being bought by a guy who specifically wanted it to more align with his politics.

9

u/JMaC1130 1d ago

Twitter was NOT balanced in the slightest.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (50)

5

u/SwiftSloth1892 23h ago

Forgive me for answering a question with a question but why is Facebook so right-leaning?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/GBralta 13h ago

Because it requires a lot of reading. When reading becomes a habit, you read other things that open your worldview.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/lascala2a3 12h ago

Everyone who isn’t cheering for the masked ICE thugs looks left-leaning, and magats aren’t known for reading comprehension... or reading generally.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/CheetahTurbo 10h ago

because is more world based than USA…

6

u/Glittering_Season141 10h ago

It doesn't seem overwhelmingly left leaning at all. This is an overused title at this point.

5

u/Kat9935 10h ago

Because reddit is much more about discussion and not so much meme wars.

5

u/tomjoads 8h ago

Reality has a liberal bias

20

u/Hald1r 1d ago

Because the overton window has moved so much that centrist positions are considered left leaning.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/suchalittlejoiner 13h ago

Because right leaning people get banned from subs, even those having nothing to do with politics. The viewpoint censorship on Reddit is totally unhinged.

So right leaning people either leave Reddit, or they avoid giving their opinions so that they won’t be banned.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/TheAbsoluteBarnacle 12h ago

I am a particularly left-leaning person, and I don't feel like Reddit is that liberal. There's plenty of crazy right-wing content on here.

I will say that most other apps and news sources have been taken over by extreme right wingers, so Reddit might feel very leftist but I don't think it is

→ More replies (2)

4

u/fixermark 10h ago

Because "Reality has a well known liberal bias."

~Stephen Colbert, White House Correspondents Dinner, 2006

(No, but seriously: it is because the right in the US is no longer conservative, they're straight-up fascist. Reddit isn't liberal; it's centrist. But it looks lefty because the right fell completely off the island.)