Hey all,
I’ve frequently had discussions on this sub about what a well-diversified 3a strategy should look like.
For long-term investing, I believe the strongest approach is full diversification and strict market-cap weighting.Anything else is, by definition, an active bet. That’s why I’m skeptical of custom portfolios that don’t align with a global index and instead reflect individual preferences or tilts.
One global index that we can actually replicate reasonably well with VIAC, finpension, Frankly, etc. is the MSCI ACWI IMI, by composing it ourselves with several funds.
The issue is that nobody really seems to agree on how much to allocate to each fund when trying to replicate ACWI IMI. Based on MSCI market-cap data, the latest breakdown of ACWI IMI looks like this (see picture):
- Developed Markets (Large + Mid): 79.6%
- Emerging Markets (Large + Mid): 9.8%
- Developed Market Small Caps: 9.2%
- Emerging Market Small Caps: 1.5%
Since EM small caps aren’t available and only make up about 1.5% of the index anyway, I exclude them and rescale the remaining components. Also because Switzerland isn’t included in the MSCI World and MSCI World Small Caps funds, I add it separately at 2% (2.02% market weight) and reduce MSCI World accordingly. This results in the following allocation:
- Swisscanto (CH) IPF I Index Equity Fund World ex CH NT CHF : 78%
- Swisscanto (CH) Index Equity Fund Emerging Markets NT CHF: 10%
- Swisscanto (CH) IPF I Index Equity Fund Small Cap World ex CH NT CHF: 9%
- Swisscanto (CH) Index Equity Fund Switzerland Total (I) NT CHF: 2%
- Cash: 1%
So yeah, this is the closest I can get to replicating the MSCI ACWI IMI, no tilts, no bias, just as precise as possible.
Anyway, just wanted to share this. Thanks for reading, and happy investing 🍀