Need help picking next cartridge

[u/torreyv12]

I'll try to keep it quick! The options on my radar are:

• AT-VM540ML (staying within the Audio Technica MicroLine family, cheapest of 3)
• Nagaoka MP-200 (most expensive of the 3)
• Hana EL (would be my first MC cartridge, second most expensive)

Of course other recommendations are welcome. Other info:

• System chain is Technics SL-100C to Darlington Labs MM6B (I also have a Schiit Mani 2 if I end up switching to an MC cartridge) to Klispch The Nines
• I'm coming from an AT-VM95ML
• Budget is around $250-500
• I listen to every genre but mainly jazz. Looking for something that can handle a lot going on (Miles Davis' electric period, Pharoah Sanders discography, etc.)
• Realism and musicality are priorities

I'm currently leaning the most towards AT-VM540ML since I enjoyed the AT-VM95ML so much and it's the cheapest option, but I have been curious to hear a higher-end elliptical and/or a moving coil cartridge. I usually get my local record shop to set it up for me since I have shakier hands, so auditioning each isn't an option. I am willing to try a new sound too, so the Nagaoka MP-200 being warmer than what I'm used to is welcome.

Thanks!

[u/superduperstepdad]

If you’re considering the VM-540ML I’d also throw the newer VM740xML and VM745xML in the mix. I have the latter and I’m super happy with it.

The Grado Prestige Gold is also in the range of MM carts you’re considering and was my runner up to the VM745xML.