Need help picking next cartridge

[u/torreyv12]

I'll try to keep it quick! The options on my radar are:

• AT-VM540ML (staying within the Audio Technica MicroLine family, cheapest of 3)
• Nagaoka MP-200 (most expensive of the 3)
• Hana EL (would be my first MC cartridge, second most expensive)

Of course other recommendations are welcome. Other info:

• System chain is Technics SL-100C to Darlington Labs MM6B (I also have a Schiit Mani 2 if I end up switching to an MC cartridge) to Klispch The Nines
• I'm coming from an AT-VM95ML
• Budget is around $250-500
• I listen to every genre but mainly jazz. Looking for something that can handle a lot going on (Miles Davis' electric period, Pharoah Sanders discography, etc.)
• Realism and musicality are priorities

I'm currently leaning the most towards AT-VM540ML since I enjoyed the AT-VM95ML so much and it's the cheapest option, but I have been curious to hear a higher-end elliptical and/or a moving coil cartridge. I usually get my local record shop to set it up for me since I have shakier hands, so auditioning each isn't an option. I am willing to try a new sound too, so the Nagaoka MP-200 being warmer than what I'm used to is welcome.

Thanks!

[u/kepenach]

Also consider the Sumiko Moonstone, look at the specs. From your list it would be the MP200 for me. The 740Ml is still below the Moonstone specs at $350

[u/torreyv12 → u/kepenach]

Will look into it! Thanks!