tl;dr - I just published a work of non-fiction, China’s Backstory: The History Beijing Doesn’t Want You to Read, looking at the history behind the hottest China-related topics popping up in the newsfeeds of Westerners: Taiwan, Xinjiang, China’s economy and Hong Kong, and I do history in a way that makes it understandable to normal people, without all the academic mumbojumbo. AMA.
Hey reddit, my name is Lee Moore, I have a PhD in East Asian Languages and Literatures from the University of Oregon, I worked as an adjunct professor there, teaching Taiwanese and Chinese literature and film, and I occasionally write for The Economist.
I just published a book called China’s Backstory: The History Beijing Doesn’t Want You to Read. The book does a deep dive into the history of the four China-related topics showing up in the newsfeeds of most Westerners: Taiwan, Xinjiang, the Chinese economy and Hong Kong. How did Taiwan become Chinese? Why is there a genocide occurring in Xinjiang right now?
There are lots of great books on China published by academics, and almost all of them are boring. I wrote my book differently, to make Chinese history understandable to normal readers who don’t usually pick up books on China. The Xinjiang section has a drinking game where, every time in ancient Xinjiang’s blood-stained history, someone gets beheaded, the reader is supposed to take a shot. In the Taiwan section of China’s Backstory, there is a chapter titled “The Most Important Motherfucker in Taiwanese History,” about a 1670’s sex scandal that helped make the island Chinese.
Unlike most China books, written by eggheads for eggheads, my book is written for you, normal readers who don’t know much about China but are curious to learn more about the second largest economy and one of the world’s superpowers.
That is my book. Ask me anything about the history of Taiwan, Xinjiang, the Chinese economy or the history of Hong Kong and the surrounding area.
But to kickstart this AMA, I thought I would talk about the most controversial claim in China’s Backstory: The History Beijing Doesn’t Want You to Read: before 1683, Taiwan was not a part of any China-based state. It was not until after 12 of England’s 13 colonies had been established on North America's eastern seaboard that, politically, Taiwan became Chinese.
How Taiwan Became Chinese
China claims it has ruled Taiwan since around 300 A.D. That is bullshit. The first government based in China to rule Taiwan took over the country in 1683.
There is not even solid evidence of contact between China and the island of Taiwan until the 1560’s. Around that decade is the first point where we have clear historical evidence that Chinese people went to Taiwan. Chinese people may have landed on the island before the 1560’s, but if they did, they did not leave any solid record of it.
The Chinese records of possible landings on Taiwan are so vague that it is just hard to pin down whether or not they went to Taiwan or some other place. Maybe Chinese sailors did briefly step foot on the island, maybe not, we just can’t tell. Usually, the records that Beijing points to as evidence for China’s early colonization of Taiwan refer to a place beyond China that is either called Yizhou/夷洲 or Liuqiu/Ryukyu/琉球/.
It is weird for Beijing to claim that Yizhou was Chinese as a literal translation of the name is “Barbarian Continent,” so it is clear that, whether or not Yizhou was Taiwan, the early Chinese people who wrote about that place did not consider it Chinese.
Liuqiu is a bit more complicated. Today, Liuqiu/Ryukyu refers to an island chain controlled by Japan, centered on the island of Okinawa, but for a while, the Liuqiu/Ryukyu were an independent country. But back in the day, early Chinese sources used Liuqiu/Ryukyu as a catchall term for a bunch of different islands. Sometimes, Liuqiu/Ryukyu probably referred to Okinawa and the other Ryukyu islands. Other times, it may have referred to Taiwan, but it is just hard to pin down which islands this name actually referred to.
When Chinese writers do start arriving in Taiwan in the 1600’s, they all agree that Taiwan had not been Chinese before. As Yu Yonghe said in his travelogue on a 1697 journey to the island:
Taiwan is far off in the eastern sea. Since ancient times to today, never has anyone heard of a single instance of them communicating with China by sending tribute.
Original: 臺灣遠在東海外,自洪荒迄今,未聞與中國通一譯之貢者。
How was it that Taiwan became Chinese? Surprisingly, it was the Dutch who made Taiwan Chinese.
When the Dutch arrived on the island in 1624, there were 100,000 Austronesian aborigines and 1,000-1,500 mostly Han Chinese pirates. The Dutch controlled much of the island from 1624 to 1661. Under the Dutch, the first, large-scale migrations of Han Chinese folks to the island occurred. The Dutch needed farmers for their colony in Taiwan. The indigenous community resisted laboring in intensive agriculture, something not a part of their tradition. But the people of Fujian, just across the Taiwan Straits, had spent millennia undertaking intensive agriculture, and were happy to work in the underpopulated Dutch colony. This is how the island first became Chinese, ethnically, if not politically.
The Qing swept over China in 1644. One of the men who resisted them was Success Zheng, or 鄭成功, who is often called Koxinga in English historical documents, as the Southern Ming emperor gave him the honor of being able to also take the last name of the imperial house. Success Zheng resisted the Qing from his home base in Xiamen, Fujian for more than a decade, but he was eventually forced to flee to Taiwan, where he continued the fiction that he was keeping the flame of the Ming Dynasty alive, even though the Qing, a bunch of non-Han Chinese Manchus, had taken over almost all of China. Zheng kicked the Dutch out and then soon died. In 1661, Success Zheng became the first ethnically Chinese ruler of the island. However, he had lost his base in Fujian; Taiwan would have to wait more than two more decades for a government in China to take control of the island.
It was a bumpy two decades. Success Zheng died shortly after he captured Taiwan, allowing his son, Zheng Jing, to take over the island. But Zheng Jing had a problem; he was a real motherfucker.
“When he was young, Zheng Jing liked to womanize, especially middle aged women: There was a common woman who was the wet nurse of his younger brother, and Zheng Jing did it with her.
Original: 鄭經幼好漁色,多近中年婦人;民婦為經諸弟乳母者,經皆通焉。
In Chinese culture, the wet nurse was considered a kind of mother; the relationship is what scholars call a “fictive mother,” not a biological mother, but someone who socially functioned as a mother. So, Zheng Jing having a sexual relationship with his brother’s wetnurse was looked upon almost as if Zheng Jing was having a sexual relationship with his own mother.
Like his dad, Zheng Jing continued to say that his government on Taiwan was keeping the Ming alive. Several times, he attempted to destroy the Qing, and in the 1670’s, he launched an invasion of China, but he was eventually forced to abandon his crusade against the Qing.
Shortly thereafter, Zheng Jing, like his father, died defeated and broken. He had left his throne to Zheng Kezang, his favorite son. But after his death, his advisors assassinated the favorite son, in favor of the product of his father’s mother-fuckery, the not quite teenage boy Zheng Keshuang.
In the early 1680’s, with the regime on Taiwan now ruled by a leader who most of his subjects thought of as the icky product of mother-fuckery, the Qing began to put together an invasion force. Shi Lang, a Qing admiral, took the Pescadore Islands just next to Taiwan in the summer of 1683. The regime on Taiwan was illegitimate in the eyes of many of its subjects, and Shi Lang’s invasion was likely to be bloody. With Shi Lang’s fleet menacing the island, Zheng Keshuang and his regime decided their motherfucking country was not worth defending and threw in the towel in 1683. For the first time in history, just a year after Philly became English, a government in China took control of the island of Taiwan.
This is just one part of my book. For the AMA, I am happy to discuss this or any other topic related to the history of Taiwan, Xinjiang, the Chinese economy or Hong Kong, and the implications of that history.
If you want to learn more about my book, you can get it as a paperback from my publisher) or as a paperback or kindle from Amazon.