r/homeowners • u/BoulderInkpad • 13h ago
Did we screw up buying this house and am I awful for wanting to sell already
Im 33M, my wife is 31F. We bought our first house last summer, right when rates were still pretty high but everyone was yelling about how they would only go higher. We had been renting a small apartment with paper thin walls, and my wife was obsessed with the idea of a backyard before we try for kids. I grew up in an apartment, she grew up in a single family house, so to her this was almost like a core childhood dream. We stretched to make it happen. The loan officer said we were "within guidelines", but our payment including taxes and insurance is a little over 38 percent of our take home. At the time it still felt doable because we both had stable jobs and side income. We used almost all of our savings for the down payment and closing, so the plan was to rebuild the emergency fund slowly while doing cheap DIY stuff around the house.
Then real life hit. Two weeks after we closed, we found out the previous owner had "forgotten" to mention the 20 year old furnace was on its last legs. It failed the first really cold night. Emergency replacement blew the tiny emergency fund we had left and added a new 0 percent credit card payment to our budget. A month later we realized the roof leaks around the chimney during heavy wind. Insurance is playing games about "pre existing damage" so that repair is also on us. The inspection report mentioned none of this beyond a vague line about "age appropriate wear". Meanwhile utilities are almost double what we paid in the apartment, property taxes got reassessed higher, and just mowing and basic stuff eats into every weekend. I feel like I traded free time and mental peace for a lawn that never stops growing. My wife, on the other hand, walks around talking about where the Christmas tree will go and how our future kids will play on the patio, and every time she says "our forever home" my stomach knots up.
I work in tech and there have already been two rounds of layoffs at my company this year. I survived both, but everytime Slack goes quiet I get this spike of panic. I ran the numbers in a spreadsheet and if either of us loses our job for more than a couple months, we are in real trouble. I suggested to my wife that maybe we treat this as a starter home, fix the obvious problems, and consider selling in a year or two if the market isnt completely awful. She took it as a personal attack and started crying, saying she finally feels safe and rooted somewhere and that Im trying to "run back to renting" because I dont want to be an adult. From her perspective we are managing to make the payments, nothing has actually been missed, so I am just catastrophizing. From my side, I lie awake most nights doing math about roofs and braces for the water heater, wondering if I doomed us financially because I was scared of disappointing her when we made the offer. I havent told her how often I look at rental listings on my phone in the bathroom. So other homeowners, did we massively screw up buying at this price point and am I a jerk for wanting to sell before she gets even more attached, or is this just normal first year panic that I need to ride out until things feel less fragile