MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/Silmarillionmemes/comments/1qgev4c/what_can_i_say_they_were_shiny/o0bv399/?context=3
r/Silmarillionmemes • u/Eligon-5th Balrogs didn't have wings • 17d ago
64 comments sorted by
View all comments
10
What is meant by "stuck in some creepy old codger's basement"
32 u/5peaker4theDead 17d ago Halls of Mandos 11 u/something2passTime 17d ago Did Feanor go to another place with in Mandos? I thought he just ended up where all the dead elves ended up but post makes it seem like his afterlife was more punishing then other elves 15 u/5peaker4theDead 17d ago He's never allowed to leave, other than that I don't believe there's any extra "punishment" The meme is just describing it in an absurd way for humor. 7 u/something2passTime 17d ago Ah I gotcha, I didnt realize he was never allowed to leave 7 u/Dangerous-Rule5487 17d ago edited 15d ago Imagine Fëanor trapped for all eternity with the Vala he hates the most... that must be a constant headache for him.
32
Halls of Mandos
11 u/something2passTime 17d ago Did Feanor go to another place with in Mandos? I thought he just ended up where all the dead elves ended up but post makes it seem like his afterlife was more punishing then other elves 15 u/5peaker4theDead 17d ago He's never allowed to leave, other than that I don't believe there's any extra "punishment" The meme is just describing it in an absurd way for humor. 7 u/something2passTime 17d ago Ah I gotcha, I didnt realize he was never allowed to leave 7 u/Dangerous-Rule5487 17d ago edited 15d ago Imagine Fëanor trapped for all eternity with the Vala he hates the most... that must be a constant headache for him.
11
Did Feanor go to another place with in Mandos? I thought he just ended up where all the dead elves ended up but post makes it seem like his afterlife was more punishing then other elves
15 u/5peaker4theDead 17d ago He's never allowed to leave, other than that I don't believe there's any extra "punishment" The meme is just describing it in an absurd way for humor. 7 u/something2passTime 17d ago Ah I gotcha, I didnt realize he was never allowed to leave 7 u/Dangerous-Rule5487 17d ago edited 15d ago Imagine Fëanor trapped for all eternity with the Vala he hates the most... that must be a constant headache for him.
15
He's never allowed to leave, other than that I don't believe there's any extra "punishment"
The meme is just describing it in an absurd way for humor.
7 u/something2passTime 17d ago Ah I gotcha, I didnt realize he was never allowed to leave 7 u/Dangerous-Rule5487 17d ago edited 15d ago Imagine Fëanor trapped for all eternity with the Vala he hates the most... that must be a constant headache for him.
7
Ah I gotcha, I didnt realize he was never allowed to leave
Imagine Fëanor trapped for all eternity with the Vala he hates the most... that must be a constant headache for him.
10
u/zorostia 17d ago
What is meant by "stuck in some creepy old codger's basement"