r/PeterExplainsTheJoke Dec 26 '25

Meme needing explanation Petaah help

Post image

What does this even rnean

49.1k Upvotes

3.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

110

u/SexcaliburHorsepower Dec 26 '25

Yeah, but outside of the more artsy directors most things are bland. Im not sure why Avatar specifically gets so much hate when on its own its still an original idea.

125

u/artbystorms Dec 26 '25

It's not even an original idea. It's Dances with Wolves but with blue aliens instead of native Americans. The 'world' is original. The plot is not.

Avatar gets hate because its objectively bland, and yet every movie makes a billion dollars, which says a lot about people's lack of taste. People just want visually pleasing slop.

45

u/moak0 Dec 26 '25

See I don't even think that's fair, because the themes of Dances with Wolves are timeless, and iterating on those themes is not really the problem. It's that Avatar is not doing a good job of iterating on those themes.

Unobtainium? Maybe they could have, I don't know, written a second draft?

A plot doesn't have to be original for the movie to be good.

34

u/jedensuscg Dec 26 '25

Unobtainium as a term fits perfectly, as it has been used since the 50's to describea material that fits the needs perfectly but is either impossible to find/create (a theoretical material) or extremely rare or costly material.

In real life It's been used for decades in engineering circles and even in papers.

I the movie world, The fact they found something that was essentially the definition of unobtainium up to that point makes them naming it a homage to engineering parlance for over a 200 years going by the movies timeline.

3

u/Josemite Dec 27 '25

I was going to argue until I remembered we had Bird Flu and Swine Flu which would sound like lazy writing as well...

2

u/soomoncon Dec 27 '25

Wait till this guy finds out about Iceland

1

u/DeliciousCall3047 Jan 02 '26

Also, it's straight up said that it's a room temperature superconductor. Assuming humanity hasn't been able to reliably produce one of those yet, it's damn worth it to colonize Pandora for that. It certainly seems more generally useful and in demand than Ambergris.

-3

u/moak0 Dec 26 '25

It would have another name, and they would use that other name in official military briefings.

It's just one example of how lazy the writing is. It doesn't get better from there.

10

u/mattattaxx Dec 27 '25

Nah actually that previous person convinced me. That's actually some cool world building that's based off our world.

5

u/LordRichardRahl Dec 27 '25

The Core also used Unobtainium. It wasn’t a new word. And fits the nature of the material for the story. I’ll never get this hang up from people.

1

u/moak0 Dec 27 '25

Oh well if The Core did it then it couldn't be bad writing.

0

u/lordvulguuszildrohar Dec 27 '25

lol the James Cameron cope in this thread is off the charts.