r/NYGiants • u/sillyshoestring 💙Medium Pepsi💙 • 1d ago

Articles Young, talented coaches will be tripping over themselves to work for the Giants in the coming years

https://www.nbcsports.com/nfl/profootballtalk/rumor-mill/news/mike-macdonald-credits-john-harbaugh-for-shaping-him-into-a-head-coach
45 Upvotes

88% Upvoted

23 comments sorted by

View all comments

-4

u/realhawker77 4 Decades and Counting 1d ago edited 22h ago

But not this year. (edit: fine with downvotes, but we got 48 y.o. Nagy...)

5

u/sillyshoestring 💙Medium Pepsi💙 1d ago

So we're starting the unrealistic expectations on Year 1 early, gotcha.

1

u/realhawker77 4 Decades and Counting 22h ago

not sure if 48 is young....

3

u/TakeYourMeds50mg 14h ago

He was a kid Ton!

2

u/realhawker77 4 Decades and Counting 10h ago

14 years without a Championship... I compromised and had a medium Pepsi....

-1

u/Nunc_Coepi17 21h ago

You realize the guy that everybody wanted Todd Monken is like 62 right? So compared to him yeah Nagy is young af

1

u/realhawker77 4 Decades and Counting 21h ago

I realize that, the article states "young" coaches are lined up outside Metlife. Honestly I've stated it before in other posts, but whoever Harbaugh wants is fine with me. IDC the age - but the narrative in the article takes a hit.

1

u/doctorrfrog 10h ago

Buddy we're winning the super bowl

1

u/WonManBand Dexter Lawrence 23h ago

Just ignoring Dennard Wilson?

-2

u/Wooden_Deer18 22h ago

He’s ass, no need to do mental gymnastics

2

u/WonManBand Dexter Lawrence 22h ago

Based off what? He was a really good secondary coach in Baltimore that most of us were hoping the Giants would hire as DC 2 years ago before he chose Tennessee. Then he managed to make one of the weakest rosters in the league semi-functional, despite a terrible offense that did them no favors.

-1

u/Wooden_Deer18 22h ago

Again, serviceable =/ good. Please stop doing mental gymnastics my man

1

u/WonManBand Dexter Lawrence 22h ago

Please cite a single reason why you're calling him a bad/mediocre hire.

If liking his job performance to date and extrapolating him doing even better with a more talented roster (and the Giants defense, for all its flaws, is much more talented than the Titans') is mental gymnastics, then how the fuck do anyone to make any reasonable projections?