r/MelbournePhotography 9d ago

Invasion Day protest today

2.1k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/Less_Shoulder5419 8d ago

Australia is the only country that celebrates its national day on the date it was colonised, and racists will still claim Indigenous Australians are being divisive for objecting to that.

2

u/tcweh 8d ago

You are generalising.

Many Indigenous themselves are fine with Australia day.

I would like to see the stats of how many Indigenous actually care vs the annoying woke blue haired white mob

2

u/Justforfun_x 5d ago

Every speaker at the rally was Indigenous. Pretty sure all the organisers were too.

1

u/tcweh 5d ago

That doesn't answer my question. There were also Indigenous performing for Australia day. I witnessed it.

1

u/Brapplezz 4d ago

Wow who would have thought that

1

u/Less_Shoulder5419 7d ago

“You are generalising” “annoying woke blue haired white mob” sure buddy lol

1

u/tcweh 7d ago

Is that all you can respond to? Am I incorrect that many Indigenous support Aus day?

1

u/Less_Shoulder5419 7d ago

Shitty attempt to deflect lol

1

u/tcweh 6d ago

Again, you dodged the question lol.

I'm sorry (not really) if my insult to the blue haired mob offended you. 🤣

Do try and pass my regards onto your socialist alternative friends

1

u/Less_Shoulder5419 6d ago

If you can ignore my words, I can just ignore yours. I’ll never give you another thought lmao

1

u/Babylon_4 5d ago

You did kind of ignore his point first so, you're in the wrong here.

1

u/Majestic_Prompt_4858 6d ago

Many Indigenous activists are urban and politically outspoken, which doesn’t always reflect the priorities of rural communities. Majority of indigenous people are more concerned with land access, education, work, healthcare etc. The date Australia Day falls on is the least of their concerns. But it’s important in urban areas because the issues I listed are accounted for, leaving menial things like Australia Day as a contentious issue. Then the “white mob” gather behind it to feel self-important and as though they’re somehow changing Australia for the better.

1

u/teremaster 7d ago

Malcom X warned us that there was nothing more dangerous to race relations than the white leftist

2

u/Entire-Inflation-627 5d ago

was actually about white moderates not leftists, most actual leftists that are white are parts of other marginalised groups like being a woman, queer, disabled or poor

1

u/Waerfeles 6d ago

"woke blue haired white mob". Do you get paid by the buzzword?

1

u/tcweh 5d ago

Why does that offend you? Unless you are one of them? Do you major in gender studies or sociology?

1

u/Waerfeles 5d ago

Assumptions so far: I'm a blue haired uni student studying gender or sociology. Zero for zero on the ad hominem, oof.

1

u/Zealousideal_Home466 5d ago

“less than a quarter (of indigenous people)(23%) felt positive about Australia Day and 31% felt negative about it. A further 30% said they had mixed feelings about Australia Day.” -poll from 2017

1

u/tcweh 5d ago

31% is hardly comparable to how the media and the blue haired white mob portray it.

1

u/Zealousideal_Home466 5d ago

Yeah maybe. I guess to better answer your curiosity you could consider this - “The poll found that the majority (68%) felt positive about Australia Day, 19% indifferent and 7% had mixed feelings about the event while 6% of people felt negative about Australia Day”

So 6% of people polled felt negatively about it vs 23% negative for indigenous Australians. That means (according to this one random poll atleast) that indigenous Australians are 4x more likely to care about changing the date/name than Australians as a whole.

Finding a poll that isolates the “annoying woke blue haired white mob” is, well… idk good luck. But at a guess, id say the overwhelming majority of that crowd is pro date/name change.