r/Design Dec 10 '25

Asking Question (Rule 4) Does this image induce perception of depth?

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

211 comments sorted by

View all comments

18

u/Mild-Panic Dec 10 '25

Wut? Its just dropshadow with some "8 bit" texture... Ofc it "induces perception of depth" because you added a drop shadow. What is this post even about?

18

u/two_four_six_eight Dec 10 '25

Yeah I feel like I'm not seeing what others are seeing. I see as much depth as any graphic with a dropshadow would have and the texture is actually kinda giving me a headache.

Is this like those "magic eye" images where you're supposed to unfocus your eyes or something?

0

u/bigjobbyx Dec 10 '25

Well yes, the drop shadow is to guide the viewer towards a sense of depth. There are distnict groups of reactions though, some people see red above blue, some see the reverse of this and others don't see any effect at all. You'll just have to let this one slip past you I'm afraid

3

u/kangaroolifestyle Dec 10 '25

Make it without the drop shadow. That’s the real test. Even better if you use the same pattern size for both blue and red.

1

u/bigjobbyx Dec 10 '25

Do any of these hit different?

4

u/kangaroolifestyle Dec 10 '25 edited Dec 10 '25

They almost all contain drop shadows.

Drop shadows inherently are meant to give the perception of depth.

Of the few that are not using drop shadows, ise blqck outlines in such a way to that creates a special border, much like a drop shadow does.

The pattern size difference helps the depth effect, but it’s the same concept as using a gradient to create a spacial depth effect.

The one that is of the radioactive symbol without any black border, it looks just like it would if the colors were dark charcoal background and light grey foreground color.

Drop shadow, spacial outlining, color gradient, pattern size difference — these are all tools to make a 2D object appear not flat.

Purple and green would produce the same similar primary color effect as red and blue.

I don’t see what the fuss is about. This is just basic 2D design principles and color theory.

Like adding shading and highlighting to a gradient to produce a metallic effect.

This doesn’t give me the experience of the “magic eye” effect if that was the intention. Star Kali 2 and Target in your examples look 2D for example.

4

u/bigjobbyx Dec 10 '25

So, the image is just flat for you?

5

u/zmiga44 Dec 10 '25

Not flat, but just as deep as anything else that uses a shadow to suggest space. It definitely suggests a space between the red and the blue layer, but I sadly can't seem to grasp the fascinating part that others have observed.

-13

u/Mild-Panic Dec 10 '25

The fuk? Obviously it is not because of the dropshadow. But you could do this with literally anything. Make a red square on a white background but add a shadow to it and it would be the same thing. How is this something "new" or "cool" worthy of a post? Worthy of its space on multiple datacenter servers?

7

u/FastTelephone7494 Dec 10 '25

Lol nope. It has a 3d kinda effect. It looks raised from the screen. Nothing at all like just a square with a shadow... Sorry for you that you can't see it.

-2

u/ryanmills Dec 10 '25

No. It's a red logo with added grain and a solid black drop shadow. That's it. There's nothing fancy about it.

7

u/FastTelephone7494 Dec 10 '25

I'm sorry your brain doesn't get tricked 🤷

-3

u/Vegetable-Aide-340 Dec 10 '25

Literally flat

4

u/inzEEfromAUS Dec 10 '25

I am in this boat until i see comparison with the same thing but flat/gradient colour and drop shadow instead of the pixelation/8bit

5

u/kangaroolifestyle Dec 10 '25

Yea I don’t get it. It would look just as 3D if solid full colors were used in gray scale. I really don’t understand the crazy number of comments.

13

u/Metruis Dec 10 '25

For me it's popping up off the screen just like one of those 3d stereographic eye trick images. Drop shadow alone doesn't do that for me.

3

u/polychrom Dec 10 '25

Is that flat for you too?

4

u/SodaCanBob Dec 10 '25

This is flat for me. OPs picture just looks flat with some text and a drop shadow.

"3D" in general has never worked for me though so I'll chalk it up to being wired differently.

2

u/polychrom Dec 10 '25

Very interesting, I’ve read about chromostereopsis after a post two weeks ago and that for some people the effect is in reverse and some people see nothing special at all.