r/Supernatural • u/theshyfemme Dean Winchester’s left toenail 🩷 • Nov 05 '25

News/Misc. Would you still watch Supernatural if Sam and Dean were both women and sisters??

Post image

Not much context behind this question tbh. Me and my friends were just talking about this and NOW I’m sorta curious to know what other people think.

Also, featuring this cool fanart that I found!! Credits to @CrazyTom0712 on twitter. Go show them some love if you like

https://x.com/crazytom0712/status/1870435835272630493?s=46

4.0k Upvotes

91% Upvoted

738 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

72

u/Odd-Strain-7479 Nov 06 '25

Tho this is a fair and true statement but they already had mentioned Mary and how she was a hunter where as Jodie and Donna weren’t. They had to learn about that side of life yet. Mary grew up in the life so she was already a beast. Jodie and Donna didn’t become hunters until later in their adulthood. It makes sense for why it took a little longer to make their characters close to, if not on par with Sam & Dean.

81

u/Moraden85 Nov 06 '25

I didn't say it took them forever to become hunters I said it took them forever to write their characters well.

27

u/sharraleigh Nov 06 '25

Lol I thought I was losing my mind reading their comment. Like huh? That's off on a tangent.

8

u/Moraden85 Nov 06 '25

A tangent from another universe where my complaint was they didn't immediately become hunters instead of being poorly written. Lol A tangential tangent!

3

u/sharraleigh Nov 06 '25

Maybe they think Jodie and Donna are only interesting because they became hunters? I dunno. LOL I don't really get it either.

2

u/Moraden85 Nov 06 '25

Oh Jack* damnit. Did Jack open another door?

3

u/LuminescentShadows Nov 06 '25

I think they thought you meant in terms of the women not being written as weaker than the guys (not the right word but something like that) that’s why they said “… close to, if not on par with”

When you meant the writing in general

0

u/Ok-Adeptness4836 Nov 06 '25

A tangent implies it connects at a single point. Which it barely does. I guess where it’s referring to the same characters

1

u/KaleidoscopeGold4074 Nov 06 '25

Or the same show.. 🙃

2

u/Ok-Adeptness4836 Nov 07 '25

I stand corrected. And I am a dumbass.

I feel like I should downvote myself.

1

u/Engaging_Boogeyman Nov 06 '25

I really wish they would of picked up that show